On Aristotle Meteorology 1.4-9, 12 (Ancient Commentators on Aristotle)
Of Philoponus' remark at the Meteorology in simple terms that on chapters 1-9 and 12 of the 1st ebook has been preserved. it truly is translated during this sequence in volumes, the 1st masking chapters 1-3; the second one (this quantity) chapters 4-9 and 12. the themes mentioned right here contain the character of fiery and lightweight phenomena within the sky, the formation of comets, the Milky approach, the homes of wet exhalation, and the formation of hail. Philoponus will pay unique cognizance to the excellence among the obvious and the true one of the sky phenomena; he criticises Aristotle's thought of the Milky manner as sublunary, and argues for its beginning within the heavenly realm; offers a close exposition of Aristotelian thought of antiperistasis, mutual substitute of the recent and the chilly, because the mechanism of condensation and similar procedures. As within the first quantity, Philoponus demonstrates scholarly erudition and familiarity with equipment and result of post-Aristotelian Greek technology. regardless of the fragmented nation of the paintings and the style of observation, the reader will locate the weather of a coherent photograph of the cosmos in line with an intensive re-thinking of Aristotelian meteorology and physics. the quantity can be of curiosity to all scholars of historical and medieval philosophy, historical past of Early glossy philosophy, background and philosophy of technological know-how.
97,11.34 lithos stone 59,20; 66,28; 120,18.20; 124,21.23; l. meteôristheis of a meteorite in Aegospotami 100,20.22; kindling stones 122,1 logizesthai calculate 105,8 emblems cause 61,39; 89,8(Ar.).16.29(Ar.); account 60,26; 90,184.108.40.206; 92,28; 99,23; 101,15; 113,2.29.34; 116,35; 117,27; 120,42; 121,31; 127,32; trademarks tês summetrias formulation for the percentage; 74,7.8; relation 56,12; 91,22; 106,34; share 126,1; argument 82,36; 83,11; 100,20; dialogue 114,15; 100,29; 101,12; 118,26; 120,34;.
‘elsewhere’ Damascius says this. yet this is often in fact hugely speculative. Introduction 25 sixteen. See pp. eight and 102-4 and nn. 359-71 lower than. 17. See Philoponus in Meteor. 59,11-13 and n. 33 advert loc. 18. See the Index of Passages mentioned. 19. Cf. 66,23-5 and n. 70 advert loc. 20. See 109,31-2 and n. 316 advert loc. 21. See 110,14 and n. 320 advert loc. 22. See 103,37 and n. 284. 23. Proclus in Tim. 3.62,22-63,20, cf. Neugebauer 1975, V B 7, 6 (918-19 and n. 9). 24. See 110,14 and n. 320 under. R. Sorabji.
Aristotle argues that the rotation of the heavens factors, by way of friction opposed to the sublunary sphere, the heating of the sublunary cosmos, with the distinctive function performed by way of the sunlight. In chapters 4-8, that are the topic Introduction five of Philoponus’ remark during this quantity, this friction remains to be the last word effective explanation for all of the procedures of ignition within the surroundings, even though every one type of occasions has particular, extra advanced and ramified, causal chains. In chapters 9-12 of publication 1,.
Produced, and a few dense non-transparent cloud involves be in the midst of the conflagration in this kind of approach that it doesn't occult the entire of it, yet basically the air that's in the midst of it, simply the place the cloud has been shaped, because the elements round the conflagration are natural and never occulted through the cloud, in such situations it occurs that the center of the conflagration now not being obvious during the black provides an visual appeal of hollowness.115 this is often additionally why issues noticeable from afar look.
Comets and capturing stars from one another. He says, simply because the movement of this type of Translation seventy seven exhalation, shaped and kindled within the method defined, looks a course and movement of a celeb also known as ‘shooting’, so too the resting country of such kindling appeared to the observers to be the resting nation of a celebrity, and this [latter form of stars] are the comets so referred to as in a extra regular feel. And back he explains the impression that arises with the aid of an instance. For it is only as.