Peeling Potatoes or Grinding Lenses: Spinoza and Young Wittgenstein Converse on Immanence and Its Logic

Peeling Potatoes or Grinding Lenses: Spinoza and Young Wittgenstein Converse on Immanence and Its Logic


“I can paintings top now whereas peeling potatoes. . . . it really is for me what lens-grinding used to be for Spinoza.”—L. Wittgenstein

More than 250 years separate the booklet of Baruch Spinoza’s Ethics and Ludwig Wittgenstein’s Tractatus Logico-Philosophicus. either are thought of enormous philosophical treatises, produced in the course of markedly varied occasions in human background, and notoriously difficult to interpret. In Peeling Potatoes or Grinding Lenses, Aristides Baltas contends that those works endure a awesome similarity according to the assumption of “radical immanence.” every one purports to appreciate the realm, suggestion, and language from the interior and in a manner resulting in the dissolution of all philosophy. In that guise, either supply a robust argument opposed to fundamentalism of all kinds and kinds.

To Spinoza, God is simply Nature. God isn't really above or become independent from the realm, humanity, or mere gadgets for, as Nature, He inheres in every little thing. To Wittgenstein, common sense isn't really above or break away language, notion, and the area. The hardness of the logical “must” inheres in states of affairs, evidence, innovations, and linguistic acts.  open air there aren't any truths or sense—only nonsense.

Through shut readings of the texts in accordance with classes drawn from radical paradigm switch in technological know-how, Baltas reveals in either works a single-minded goal, implacable reasoning, and an austerity of favor which are infrequent within the historical past of philosophy. He analyzes the constitution and content material of every treatise, the authors’ intentions, the constraints and percentages afforded by way of clinical discovery of their respective eras, their radical competition to triumphing philosophical perspectives, and attracts out the details, in addition to the results, of the arresting fit among the two. 

Show sample text content

Download sample